Properly Proper Pimento Cheese the Sharp Creamy Southern Staple

"Properly Proper" Pimento Cheese: The Sharp & Creamy Southern Staple

You know that feeling when you bite into something so perfectly comforting, it’s like getting a proper hug from your Nan? That’s what we’re chasing today. I’m talking about making the absolute best Pimento Cheese Spread you’ve ever tasted.

Forget that sad, orange paste you see in tubs; this homemade version sings.

The Sensory Hook

The aroma alone sharp cheese mingling with that subtle sweetness from the peppers is enough to make your stomach rumble. This isn't just a dip; it’s the real deal Southern treat. If you want flavour that punches above its weight class and takes about fifteen minutes of your time, stick with me.

This Pimento Cheese Spread recipe is about to become your go-to.

Getting Straight to the Point

I know why you’re here. You’re probably wondering: "How do I stop it from being greasy?" or "Which cheese actually gives that perfect tang?" Good questions. Most other blogs just list ingredients.

We fix texture issues, we nail the sharp cheddar ratio, and we promise you the best pimento cheese spread recipe you’ll ever need. No soggy results here, mate.

Level Up Your Spread Game

The secret to knocking spots off those supermarket tubs? It’s grating your own cheese, full stop. Seriously, ditch the pre-shredded stuff; it’s coated in anti caking powder and ruins the smooth texture we need for a silky cream cheese pimento cheese spread .

We are aiming for that iconic, tangy flavour of a true Southern pimento cheese spread .

Right then, let’s get those ingredients sorted. Don’t worry, this is dead easy no cooking required, just good mixing.

Related Recipes Worth Trying

• Cracking Good Mini Cheesecakes with Vanilla Wafers FailProof Easy for Parties — Ditch the faff These individual Mini Cheesecakes with Vanilla Wafers are perfectly portable twobite desserts Get the easy nobake recipe for cream cheese and...
• No Bake Banana Pudding Cheesecake Grandmas Recipe — This no bake banana pudding cheesecake is pure comfort Creamy dreamy and easy even a novice can whip it up Get ready for the ultimate banana dessert
• Cherry Cheesecake Dream Dump Cake Easiest Recipe Ever — Whip up this ridiculously easy cherry cheesecake dump cake Creamy dreamy and ready in under an hour The perfect lazy dessert recipe Get the details now

Right then, let’s get cracking on a truly smashing recipe for Pimento Cheese Spread. This isn't just any dip, mind you; it’s the King of Southern Spreads, a proper taste of tradition that belongs on any respectable picnic blanket.

We’re aiming for something sharp, creamy, and perfectly seasoned not the dreadful stuff you find lurking at the back of the supermarket fridge! Making your own homemade pimento cheese spread is dead easy, promise.

Core Shopping List

First things first, we need the right gear. Quality matters here, especially with cheese! For the main event, you’ll need 8 ounces (225 grams) of seriously sharp Cheddar. Don’t cheap out; if it doesn’t make your eyes water a bit, it’s not sharp enough.

We’re mixing that with 4 ounces (115 grams) of Monterey Jack for melt and silkiness.

Crucially, buy the cheese in blocks. Pre-shredded stuff is coated in anti caking agents, which leaves you with a gritty disaster. We also need 4 ounces (115 grams) of full fat cream cheese, softened and I mean softened , leave it out for at least an hour.

Finally, grab 1/4 cup (60 ml) of good quality mayonnaise. If you’re feeling fancy, use one you’d happily eat on a proper prawn cocktail.

Flavour Architecture

This is where we move beyond just cheese and mayo. The backbone of this Sharp pimento cheese spread relies on umami and depth. We use a tiny dash of Worcestershire sauce just 1 teaspoon (5 ml) —to give it that savoury hit that separates the novices from the dab hands.

Don't skip it!

For aromatics, we’re keeping it simple and pantry friendly: 1/2 teaspoon (2.5 ml) of onion powder and 1/4 teaspoon (1.25 ml) of garlic powder. Then, for that little lift, a mere pinch of cayenne.

You don’t want it hot, just warm, like a gentle hand on your shoulder. If you absolutely cannot find pimento peppers, you can substitute with finely diced roasted red bell peppers, but frankly, that’s just not the same for a true Southern pimento cheese spread . My own top tip?

Always taste before adding salt; those sharp cheddars can pack a surprising sodium punch.

Equipment & Mise en Place

No need for fancy gadgets, thank goodness. Your essential tool is a box grater, or better yet, a food processor with a grating disc if you’re feeling lazy. You’ll also need a large mixing bowl and a sturdy rubber spatula.

My top mise en place tip, especially if you’re hoping to knock this out quickly for an impromptu Pimento Cheese Spread sandwich recipe , is to grate all your cheeses first and set them aside.

Then, measure out all your powders into one tiny bowl your ‘seasoning shot.’ Once your cream cheese is properly soft, the whole process takes about ten minutes flat. Remember to drain those pimentos really well. I learned this the hard way once; soggy peppers make for watery spread.

Chill it for at least 30 minutes before serving; trust me, that resting time makes this the best pimento cheese spread recipe around. It turns a good mix into a great dip!

Right then, let’s get this Pimento Cheese Spread recipe sorted properly. This isn't just some sad little dip, is it? We’re talking about the King of Spreads here. If you’ve only ever bought the pale, rubbery stuff from the supermarket, prepare to have your mind blown.

We’re making the real deal that sharp, unapologetic Southern pimento cheese spread that tastes like a sunny afternoon in Georgia.

Before You Cook

First things first, we need to stage our setup. While our rivals might rush straight into mixing, we take a moment. Your main time commitment here is waiting for the flavours to hug each other properly.

You want to give this mixture at least 30 minutes chilling time after mixing. Seriously, don't skip it. If you try to serve it straight away, the texture is all wrong, and the flavour tastes flat like a lukewarm cup of tea.

That’s my hard learned lesson from batch one years ago!

The biggest pitfall here is texture. If you use pre-grated cheese, you'll end up with something gritty, not creamy. We avoid that blandness trap entirely by grating our own block cheese. Trust me on this one; it’s non-negotiable for the best pimento cheese spread recipe .

Guided Cooking Sequence

This is more of an assembly job than cooking, which is brilliant for a weeknight!

1. The Creamy Foundation: Get your softened cream cheese and mayonnaise into a big bowl. Beat them until they look like smooth, pale velvet. I mean smooth . If you see any lumps, keep going! This forms the base of our Cream cheese pimento cheese spread .
2. Flavour Punch: Whack in the Worcestershire sauce, onion powder, garlic powder, cayenne, and black pepper. Give it a good stir so those spices wake up.
3. Cheese In: Now, gently fold in your mountain of freshly grated cheddar and Monterey Jack. Use a spatula, not a whisk! We want it just combined. Overmixing compresses the cheese, making the final result heavy. You’re looking for that lovely, fluffy, shredded texture.
4. Pimento Fold: Drain your pimentos exceptionally well I pat mine dry between paper towels. Then, fold them in gently. We don't want pink mush; we want distinct pops of pepper.
5. The Rest: Transfer your beautiful mixture into a container. Press some cling film right onto the surface to stop a skin forming a classic rookie error, that. Pop it in the fridge for at least 30 minutes . This chilling time is mission critical for developing that sharp, deep flavour that defines a great Homemade pimento cheese spread .

Save-It Section

This Pimento Cheese Spread actually gets better overnight. The sharp cheddar mellows slightly, and everything melds beautifully. Store it in an airtight tub in the fridge for up to five days. If you’re making it for a party, I usually make it the day before.

It’s perfect for a quick Pimento cheese spread sandwich recipe the next morning, too!

If you taste it and think, "Blimey, that's a bit too tangy," you can quickly fix it by stirring in an extra teaspoon of mayo. If it tastes a bit dull, a tiny sprinkle of fine salt usually sorts that right out.

It’s an easy pimento cheese spread that’s tough to mess up, but even easier to salvage if you do! Serve it chilled, perhaps as a fantastic pimento cheese dip alongside some salty crisps. Job done.

Right then, let’s have a proper chinwag about finishing this absolute belter of a Pimento Cheese Spread recipe . We’ve done the hard work mixing, and now it’s time to make it sing on the plate.

Taste & Texture Upgrades

When I first started making this years ago, my spread always looked a bit… sad. Like it had been left out since Tuesday. The trick, and this is non-negotiable, is grating your own cheese. Pre-shredded stuff is coated in potato starch, which gives you a gritty texture, not the creamy silkiness we're after.

For a proper restaurant finish, try topping the finished bowl with a drizzle of good quality olive oil and a sprinkle of smoked paprika right before serving. That little bit of shimmer really ups the ante.

If you’re making a Pimento Cheese Spread sandwich recipe later, you want this spread firm. If you’re using it as a dip, let it sit out for 15 minutes before serving so it’s soft enough to scoop easily.

I find many recipes, like that one from that big TV chef, overdo the mayo. We only use enough to bind, keeping the cheese flavour front and centre, which makes our Sharp Pimento Cheese Spread miles better.

Nutrition & Dietary Paths

Now, I’m not one for counting every single calorie like a hawk, but it’s useful to know roughly what you're tucking into. Per serving (say, 2 tablespoons), you’re looking at about 180 calories, primarily from the fats in the cheese and mayo, but you get a good hit of protein too around 9 grams.

If you need to lighten this up, ditch the full fat mayo and use a reduced fat one, or better yet, swap half the mayo for full fat Greek yogurt. It adds a lovely tang, though the texture will be slightly firmer when cold. For a dairy-free version?

That’s a whole other kettle of fish, but substituting with cashew cream or a high-quality vegan cream cheese alternative works in a pinch. You lose that authentic Southern punch, but hey, needs must sometimes!

Serving & Pairing Ideas

This Easy Pimento Cheese Spread is unbelievably versatile. If you’re having people over, serve it cold as a Pimento Cheese dip with some homemade spiced pecans and celery sticks.

If you want something more substantial, it’s divine melted into a toastie; you’ll want to use this mixture for a proper Pimento Cheese Spread sandwich recipe .

make-ahead? Absolutely! This keeps cracking in the fridge for about five days. Just remember to press plastic wrap right onto the surface before sealing the lid it stops that awful dry skin forming. When reheating to melt for a sauce, use a very low heat on the stovetop, stirring constantly.

Never microwave it straight from the fridge, or it’ll split faster than a cheap umbrella in a gale!

Honestly, once you try this, you’ll never go back to the tubs. This truly is the Best pimento cheese spread recipe out there. Do give it a whirl this weekend and let me know how you jazz yours up!

If you're craving more ideas, explore Proper Lush Welsh Rarebit My Ultimate Cheese Toast Upgrade , Salami Cream Cheese Roll Ups Easy Pinwheel Party Bites and Black Bottom Bliss My Familys Cream Cheese Cupcakes .